How one joke harmed Merlot sales for years | Nudge Newsletter 🧠


The joke that killed Merlot.

In 2004 the movie Sideways featured the character Miles, a wine connoisseur on a tour of wineries in California.

Miles, a heartbroken, miserable divorcé, who, in an effort to cheer himself up, goes on a wine tour with his friend Jack.

The film did wonders for the sales of Santa Barbara wines. Except for one variety: merlot.

Here’s why:

video preview​

​

Miles opted for pinot noir instead, for which sales have since skyrocketed.

When Sideways premiered in 2004, merlot made up close to 20 percent of California’s red wine market. A few years later, it dropped to 13 percent.

In the same period, pinot noir sales grew 16 percent.

Simply believing that the masses prefer pinot noir-results in us following that behaviour.

We change our behaviour, our memory, our actions, and our beliefs to match the herd.

Cheers,

Phill

P.S. This summer, the incredibly smart folks over at Habit Weekly are hosting a Behavioral Design Bootcamp.

Attendees will gain insights into BS models, improve behavioral design skills, access key resources, connect with peers on Slack, and join live expert-led sessions (potentially a session led by me...).

To join you'll need to subscribe to Habit Weekly Pro. It's good value and if you use the code "nudge" you'll get 50% off annual and lifetime memberships. Sign up here.

This isn't sponsored, I just really like the work Samuel and his team are doing.

Nudge Newsletter

I spend 18 hours each week turning marketing psychology into readable newsletters.

Read more from Nudge Newsletter

It's rhyme time. Rhymes are strangely powerful. Researchers McGlone and Tofighbakhsh found that rhymes boost believability by 17% Filkukova and Klempe found that rhyming slogans are rated at 22% more accurate. Shotton and Thompson found that rhymes boost recall by 29%. So it's no surprise that Tesco now use rhymes to reassure customers that its reduced produce is still "just as nice". There's not a single reduced item remaining. Clearly, the rhymes are working. But Tesco is hardly alone....

Flawless is worthless. Adam Grant shared a study of world-class sculptors in his book Hidden Potential. It turns out that world-class sculptors were average students. 66% graduated high school with Bs and Cs. A similar pattern emerged when comparing America's most influential architects. The great architects had rarely been great students: they typically finished college with a B or C average. Adam Grant writes how, in their quest for flawless results, research suggests that perfectionists...

How I pitch Nudge. I sent marketing influencer Tom Goodwin a cold email asking him to come on Nudge. He responded with this. What a lovely thing to say. Buoyed by this praise, I thought I'd break down the nudges I included in my pitch. 1: Credible social proof This one speaks for itself. 2: Input bias Most pitches don't bother to research guests and suggest a bespoke topic. I do. 3: Halo effect Picturing well-known marketing profs beside my dumb face will make Tom believe I'm more credible...